You Get What You Pay For: The True Cost of a "DISCOUNT" Listing Commission

We've all been there. You're selling your home, and the listing commissions start rolling in. One agent offers a seemingly irresistible low rate, promising to save you thousands. It's tempting, right? But before you sign on the dotted line, let's talk about the real cost of a "cheap" listing commission. Because sometimes, "saving" money upfront can lead to losing a lot more in the long run.

The Allure of the Low Commission

It's understandable to want to maximize your profit when selling your home. Every dollar counts. A lower commission seems like a direct way to achieve that. However, the reality is often more complex. Just like you wouldn’t choose the cheapest surgeon or cut corners with your financial advisor, hiring a discount real estate agent can end up costing you far more in the long run. Think about it— even if you pay a half or even a full percent more in commission for your listing agent, but your agent’s expertise gets you 2% more on your sale price, that’s a smart investment. In real estate, as in other professional services like medicine or finance, you truly get what you pay for—and a skilled, strategic agent can make all the difference in both your experience and your bottom line and are worth their weight in gold when it comes to protecting your biggest investment.

In real estate, it’s easy to be swayed by polished pitches and rehearsed answers, but to truly find an agent who will go the distance to sell your home, you have to peel back the onion—because while some agents are great interviewers and have learned all the right things to say with little follow-through, others pair strong communication skills with real, results-driven substance. For that reason we are also providing you some helpful interview tips to get at some of these differentiators.

What You Might Be Sacrificing trying to save on commission:

• Marketing Power:

  • A top-tier agent invests heavily in professional photography, virtual tours, targeted online advertising, high-quality brochures, and other key marketing and advertising activities. These tools are paid for by your agent and are crucial for attracting serious buyers and showcasing your home's best features. A budget-conscious agent may cut corners here, resulting in less exposure and fewer offers. Think of it this way: a higher quality professional photographer/videographer can make your home shine online, while poor photos can deter potential buyers.

  • Often, less expensive agents rely solely on the basic listing services provided, which is the baseline and what every brokerage offers. A seasoned, successful agent will have their own set of specialized tools and strategies that actively drive sales. Brokerages provide the stage, agents provide the performance. A successful home sale relies on the agents investment of time, money, and expertise.

  • A common tactic among lower cost agents is to place the property on the MLS and hope for the best, rather than using a strategic marketing plan to find a buyer. An agent who invests in these services demonstrates a commitment to maximizing your home's potential, and often recoups the cost through a higher sale price. 

  • INTERVIEW TIP: When interviewing agents ask them to share all the marketing strategies they offer to get your home sold. Then after they have answered the question, ask them to differentiate which of those services the brokerage offers to every agent versus what additional strategies and services they themselves employ to get your home sold. This will help you determine what value that specific agent is really adding versus what you could get from every agent out there. When the agent relies soley on the standard brokerage pitch, that could be a flag. After all, the brokerage doesn't sell your home, the agent does. Another key question is to ask them for actual examples of this work and follow on to inquire about the impact of the marketing they do and look for tangible results.

• 

  

  
  
  

• Property Preparation Focus:

  • Agents who rush to snap a few photos and quickly get your home listed might seem efficient, but they often skip one of the most important steps in achieving a successful sale: thoughtful property preparation. Taking the time to properly prepare a home—through strategic staging, minor repairs, curb appeal enhancements, and professional photography—can significantly impact how buyers perceive the property and, ultimately, how quickly and profitably it sells. A well-prepared home not only looks better in photos but also feels more inviting during showings, creating an emotional connection that drives interest and competitive offers. In today’s market, presentation is everything, and cutting corners at the outset can mean leaving money on the table.

  • Some agents offering higher commissions also include property preparation oversight and property enhancement staging services. This can involve anything from decluttering and minor repairs to staging services to add decor accents and sometimes furnishings when needed. These services can dramatically enhance your home's appeal, leading to faster sales and higher offers.

  • INTERVIEW TIP: When interviewing agents ask them what the timeline is for getting your home listed. This will give you an idea of whether they take the necessary up-front time to get your home ready for prime time to increase your chances of an effective sale. This is another area to ask them for examples of their work. Have them show you before and afters of the homes they have listed to ensure you aren't just seeing beautifully prepared homes that were delivered that way by the home owners.

    

    
    

• Negotiation Expertise:

  • Negotiating the best possible price and terms requires skill and experience. A seasoned agent knows how to navigate complex situations, handle multiple offers, and advocate for your interests. A less experienced or less motivated agent might leave money on the table.

  • Furthermore, consider this: if an agent couldn't effectively negotiate a fair commission rate for their own services, how confidently can you trust them to negotiate the best possible price for your most valuable asset, your home? A strong negotiator demonstrates their value from the very beginning and a skilled negotiator can often deliver sales results that far outweigh the difference in commission.

  • INTERVIEW TIP: When interviewing agents ask them to walk you through their negotiation approach. You may also want to ask them to give you real examples. Also keep in mind that how an agent handles the commission conversation is a real-time example of their negotiation skills—if they can’t confidently advocate for their own value, how effectively will they negotiate on your behalf when thousands (or tens of thousands) of your dollars are on the line?
    

• Market Knowledge and Strategy:

  • A knowledgeable agent understands the local market trends, pricing strategies, and buyer behavior. They can help you price your home accurately, attract the right buyers, and avoid costly mistakes. An agent with limited experience might misjudge the market, leading to a longer selling time or a lower sale price.

  • A seasoned agent can also anticipate and navigate potential roadblocks, such as inspection issues, appraisal discrepancies, or contract complications, minimizing stress and protecting your financial interests.

  • INTERVIEW TIP: When interviewing agents ask them to share materials they use to keep the public and clients aware of the market conditions. Is what they are publishing canned information from the brokerage or do they add their own insights? Ask them about the current conditions and see if they can respond to 2nd tier deeper dive questions.

    

    

    
    
    

• Service and Communication:

  • Selling a home is a stressful process. A dedicated agent provides consistent communication, prompt responses, and personalized service. A "cheap" agent might be stretched thin, leading to delays, missed calls, and a frustrating experience.

  • A top-tier agent proactively anticipates potential issues, provides timely updates, and remains readily available to address your concerns, ensuring a smoother and less stressful transaction.

  • INTERVIEW TIP: When interviewing agents, ask them to walk you through the type and frequency of communication you can expect throughout the sales process. Don’t just settle for vague promises—request real examples of past updates, reports, or check-ins they've provided to other clients. This helps ensure you're not just getting a polished answer, but a clear picture of how they’ll actually keep you informed and supported every step of the way.
    

• Network and Connections:

  • Agents build networks of other agents, buyers, and service providers. A well connected agent can get your home in front of more potential buyers.

  • A well-established agent has cultivated relationships with reputable professionals, such as inspectors, contractors, and attorneys, ensuring you receive reliable and high-quality referrals throughout the selling process.

  • INTERVIEW TIP: Ask the agent about their network—how do they leverage their relationships with other agents and industry professionals to benefit your sale? A strong answer will go beyond name-dropping and include specific ways they’ve used their connections to attract buyers, solve problems quickly, or streamline the process with trusted vendors.
    

The Real Cost of "Saving" Money

Consider this alternative: You choose the low-cost option, and your home is presented with subpar visuals, minimal marketing and passive sales techniques. While you saved on the commission, you missed out on attracting serious, qualified buyers who were drawn to professionally presented properties. The result? A prolonged listing period and a sale price far below what a strategic, well-marketed approach could have achieved.

The Bottom Line

While a low commission might seem appealing, it's essential to consider the long-term implications. Choosing a knowledgeable, experienced, and dedicated agent can make a significant difference in your final sale price and overall experience. A higher commission signifies a greater value proposition. You're paying for an agent who brings a wealth of experience, a robust marketing plan, and a commitment to achieving the best possible outcome. It's the difference between simply listing your home and actively selling it for top dollar.

Don't just focus on the commission rate. Focus on the value you're receiving. In the world of real estate, you truly get what you pay for. With her knowledge and network, Renee Hahn ensures you make informed decisions that benefit both your home and the environment. For more information, reach out to her at (239) 287-2576 or via email at renee@yournaplesexpert.com.